Days 8 and 9 – Finding Blogs to Comment and Join Discussions!
There have been many questions about how to find the best blogs to start your commenting strategy! Before I start showing a few of the ways you can, I want to reiterate one very specific thing… Do not Spam other Blogs with Comments! You will do nothing more than have your comments deleted and may even piss off the site owner. One way or another, it is nothing more than wasting your own time… and as we all know, time is the one thing we do not want to waste!
Why Comment on Other Blogs?
In order to work out your own best strategy… its important to understand WHY you want to comment on other blogs. The purpose of a blog in the first place is to build a community a readers who are all interested in that same topic. By finding related blogs and joining in their discussions, you will start building a community of your own as the visitors of their site, are likely to be the same target of your own. As long as you are true to the discussion and provide topic related comments, your own readership and traffic will increase as well!
Comment your Posts – Not just your Entire Blog!
Your new website is not a 1 page site and your comment strategy must take that into account! In other words, as you travel the web looking for discussions to share your own content, do not focus on your main page only.
For example, my new site may be about DIY Projects, but one of my last posts was about DIY Halloween Costumes. As I travel the web today… I am going to look for discussions related to making your own Halloween Costumes and for the anchor URL, I will use my post for the link, not the main site root!
Finding Blogs to Comment and Join Discussions
There are several ways you can go about finding the right blogs to join discussions. One way, is to just use the Google blog search! Head over and search for a few of your tags or keywords in your post and Google will return a list of blog posts on the topic! You have the option of narrowing them down to recent posts… or just about as far back as you want to go.
I know someone is going to ask… “Should I Comment on Old Posts? So I will answer it ahead of time… If you want to bring live visitors to your site, why would you bother commenting on a 2 year old post, UNLESS it still has active comment discussion going on today!
For visitors, I will choose to limit the results to posts in the last 24 hours… this will return a group of results that are recently published and most likely to send traffic to my own post on the topic.
Taking the Low Road – Why Commenting got a Bad Name
On the dark side of this… If an older post has pagerank, the site has authority, and the blog participates in using Do Follow links on their comments, you can gain quite a bit of authority of your own by adding a comment to the post, as long as the site owner still approves comments on older posts.
Purely hypothetically speaking, if I wanted to increase my own site authority, I could go through the OLDER posts and with a few extra steps, choose only those that are allowing do-follow in their comments. By submitting to these… I am more likely to increase my own site authority quicker. Firefox even has an SEO plugin that will highlight the nofollow links for you so you know immediately if a site uses sends juice to yours or not.
If you want to try out a tool that searches all blogs and returns a list of do-follow posts, sorts them by pagerank and date, try the free version of Fast Blog Finder (Free download link) or visit their homepage to read more. I used it this morning for the first time and got an immediate list of 3 do-follow blog posts with PR4 using the free edition! With the $49 paid version, it returns unlimited results… meaning you could get a list of hundreds of do-follow posts to comment on!
Hypothetically… If I really want to get the most of dofollow blogs, I could post on older posts with existing authority. As soon as I see my comment live on the site, I could then add the link to that post to my own social bookmarking accounts and update them. Taking it one step farther… I could ping my own bookmark pages to update services, telling google and other search engines that my page has been updated. They come to my page and follow the links to those pages that contain my do follow link, follow those links to my site pages, thus getting immediate indexing. :-) BUT… this is purely hypothetical.
Debunking the No Follow Beliefs
Just because a link is coded with no-follow, DOES NOT mean its actually NOT followed! Read the Wikipedia nofollow pageto get a true understanding, much more indepth than I will go. Even Google, who is largely responsible for promoting this no follow tag to stop pagerank manipulation, follows the links! If the page is already in the google index, it will even reindex it! Yahoo completely ignores the no follow tag and MSN is yet to tell us what they do with it!
My Tasks for Days 8 & 9
-
One new Blog post per day (Sound familiar?)
-
Submit my site to 10 more blog directories
-
Comment on 5 related blog posts
-
Update my own link pages and ping the updates to blog search engines
How else do you find related blogs to join the discussions?
Previously Published Articles You May Like to Read:
- Days 3 & 4 – Finding Sources for Content Ideas!
- Days 10 & 11 – Rewarding your Visitors with Authority Content!
- How Do You Get People to Comment on your Sites?







Mark,
For your DIY Reviews website what WP template are you using???
David
@ David -
I coded it myself… 100% homegrown inhouse!
I had originally planned on making it a distribution theme, but after realizing all of the code work that goes into getting categories set as well as the custom script I had made for the top 100 list, I decided against it.
Mark
Here’s another newbie question……how do you ping the updates to blog search engines. How do you manually ping.
Julie
I have a list of site for pinging if that’s any help
Here it is
http://api.feedster.com/ping
http://api.feedster.com/ping.php
http://api.moreover.com/RPC2
http://bblog.com/ping.php
http://blog.goo.ne.jp/XMLRPC
http://blogbot.dk/io/xml-rpc.php
http://blogdb.jp/xmlrpc
http://blogmatcher.com/u.php
http://blogoole.com/ping
http://blogroots.com/tb_populi.blog?id=1
http://blogsearch.google.com/ping/RPC
http://blogsnow.com/ping
http://blogupdate.org/ping/
http://coreblog.org/ping
http://effbot.org/rpc/ping.cgi
http://godesigngroup.com
http://godesigngroup.com/blog/feed
http://imblogs.net/ping
http://lasermemory.com/lsrpc
http://mod-pubsub.org/kn_apps/blogchatt
http://ping.amagle.com/
http://ping.bitacoras.com
http://ping.blogg.de
http://ping.bloggers.jp/rpc
http://ping.blogmura.jp/rpc
http://ping.cocolog-nifty.com/xmlrpc
http://ping.fakapster.com/rpc
http://ping.myblog.jp
http://ping.rootblog.com/rpc.php
http://ping.sg/rpc/colorfulmars/moon
http://ping.weblogs.se
http://ping.wordblog.de
http://pinger.blogflux.com/rpc
http://pingoat.com/goat/RPC2
http://pingqueue.com/rpc
http://rcs.datashed.net/RPC2
http://rpc.blogbuzzmachine.com/RPC2
http://rpc.britblog.com
http://rpc.tailrank.com/feedburner/RPC2
http://rpc.wpkeys.com
http://rpc.technorati.com/rpc/ping
http://signup.alerts.msn.com/alerts-PREP/submitPingExtended.doz
http://snipsnap.org/RPC2
http://trackback.bakeinu.jp/bakeping.php
http://weblogues.com/RPC
http://www.a2b.cc/setloc/bp.a2b
http://www.blogpeople.net/servlet/weblogUpdates
http://www.blogshares.com/rpc.php
http://www.catapings.com/ping.php
http://www.feedsky.com/api/RPC2
http://www.focuslook.com/ping.php
http://www.godesigngroup.com
http://www.holycowdude.com/rpc/ping
http://www.imblogs.net/ping
http://www.mod-pubsub.org/kn_apps/blogchatter/ping.php
Hope this is useful
Cherie
@ Julie –
There is alot of software that will do this for you… but you can also just head to some of their ping submit pages like: http://blogsearch.google.com/ping and submit your urls manually.
Mark
Mark,
Just to make sure I’m following let me use a real life example of your-hypothetical-strategy.
I first go to your blog which I’ve found is related to my blog’s niche and has authority and leave an honest opinion or comment. When I see it has been approved, I go to my Delicious bookmarks and add the link to my comment on your site. After I’ve done that I go to google blog search and ping my bookmark page.
This way, I’ve gotten at least two more links for the price of one comment?
Can you use stumbleupon or twitter for the middle step or is it important that it’s specifically a bookmarking site?
Jeff
@ Jeff –
You are spot on!
1 – Comment
2 – Add the page you commented on to your own Bookmark page(s)
3 – Submit your own bookmark page to blog ping sites.
Alternatively, you can leave your own page out of the mix completely and just submit the page you commented on as well. Steps 1 & 3 will do just as good.
The reason to ping your own sites is that if you do it regularly, the ping sites will just visit on their own more often, thus eliminating the third step completely over time. This also adds to your authority, since you are BM’ing only your own sites.
Mark
@ Flatten your Tummy –
GREAT list of rpc hosts for sure!! The only thing you should be careful about, is that some of the services like PingGoat, do not also submit to others in your list.
Ex: You submit to PingGoat, and it submits to others in your list. When you also submit to those same directories, it may be tagged spam if they come from the same IP.
WordPress suggests using http://rpc.pingomatic.com/ as the main ping tool, and what I do from there is use Feedburners tools to include some others, not automatically hit with the pingomatic tool.
Mark
Mark, would this work the same for forums? Also, if a blog you are commenting on has decent pagerank, but the specific post you are commenting on doesn’t have any, is there any point in getting the link?
Mark G.
The PR factor is great for posts that use do-follow, but even if the domain has pr, its good to comment on non-pr posts.
You never know how popular a new post will become, your 0 pr comment today, may be a pr5 one day!
Is your frontline site new? I saw it was only regged in Sept, but when did you actually make it live to visitors?
Mark
Mark, it was completed three or four weeks ago. I have had trouble getting google to index it. Linked to it from Ebay, squidoo, social bookmarking sites, nothing so far. Do you ask for a specific reason?
@ Mark G –
Yes, I wanted to see how long it was active to see if it was dropped already. In your cPanel stats, do you see ANY reference at all from Google at anytime since the site was purchased and went live?
In Sept, you should see some activity from G…
It is WELL indexed in Yahoo… which usually takes longer than G. I am curious if Google is deindexing BANS only sites that quickly now!
Mark
Mark, yes, I don’t see activity from google after about the beginning of the month. I made the mistake of allowing google to access it while I was building it. Maybe it was indexed and deindexed before I knew that either had happened. There’s not a ton of extra stuff on it, but its not an out of the box bans store, either. Funny thing is I have a thinner bans site that has stayed well indexed for seven months now. I’m going to hope that yahoo will send traffic, and I’ll promote through other means, i guess.
@ Mark G –
Googlebot will likely continue coming regardless… but its the referred traffic that tells the tale. Since none of the site pages are in the Google index, its safe to assume it was a drop.
I could tell immediately it was not a cut and run BANS site… which is why I wanted to check with you on it. It looks like they may have found a way to ID bans sites with an algorithim, because your site has alot of useful content.
Mark
Mark
I hope this is a bans thing, and not a wp/bans thing. I won’t be building any without WP attached, with this one I just didn’t think it was something I could really blog about. Oh well, thanks for the guidance and keep up the good work.
[...] someone gets all worked up, I’m not talking about spam… I’m talking about finding related blogs that use the Top Commentator, or some sort of commenter reward plugin and engaging in meaningful [...]
Are You Too Set In Your Ways?
Site Categories
Monthly Archive
My Favorite Places
Blogging Sites
Blogroll
Places I Write
Technology Sites
Site Credits
Niche Store Builder is powered by WordPress, using a modified theme originally inspired by Arthemia.
Home | About | Terms & Privacy